What a mayoral election in New York taught me about character

Elections are often described as tests of popularity, policy or management, yet their sharper lesson can be about character. A candidate can inherit an impossible city, divide a coalition and still persuade us that he or she deserves our confidence. I have come to regard “What a Mayoral Election in New York Taught Me About Character” as a study of that pressure: what remains visible in a person when rhetoric, ambition and public expectation all press against it.

My reference point is New York’s 1965 mayoral contest between John Lindsay and James J. Farley. The names summon different kinds of political power: Lindsay brought reformist energy and an unusual coalition; Farley brought the instincts of a seasoned city operator. I did not treat the result as a morality play. The lesson lay in watching how people behaved before victory, around people they considered insignificant, and when a compromise carried a cost.

A contest larger than the count

The election unfolded in a New York divided by neighbourhood, class, race, religion and the enormous differences between Manhattan and the outer boroughs. Residents could share a city while living in separate political worlds. A candidate seeking the mayor’s office had to speak across those divisions without pretending they did not exist. That requirement made personal conduct more than a private concern. It became part of the candidate’s credibility.

Farley came from the world of Irish-American political networks, organised patronage and the practical service that kept a city functioning. Lindsay came from reform politics, academic seriousness and a determination to enlarge public discussion. Their backgrounds suggested different sources of strength, but each man also carried weaknesses. Farley could appear to treat government as a machine of personal obligations. Lindsay could seem remote, polished or more interested in principle than in the daily mechanics of neighbourhood life.

The count complicated any easy judgement. Farley received more votes overall, while Lindsay won enough district victories to secure the weighted electoral result. That division taught me to separate character from the final tally. A candidate may possess admirable qualities and still make poor decisions. A candidate may win through tactical skill without becoming a trustworthy public servant. Integrity has to be judged across many choices, including the unattractive ones that produce no applause.

The city reveals the pressure points

Housing, employment, schools, transport and policing shaped every campaign conversation. A broken lift in a subway station, a crowded classroom or a neighbourhood frightened by the police carried more political meaning than a polished policy paper. These were not peripheral subjects. They were the conditions in which people lived, and they exposed who a politician was prepared to notice.

Character appeared in small details: whether a candidate remembered a meeting, arrived on time, accepted an unwelcome fact or continued speaking after the room had become uncomfortable. Crowds rewarded volume and confidence. The harder task was to remain steady without becoming stubborn, to listen without offering empty sympathy, and to distinguish a necessary compromise from the surrender of a principle. New York offered an education in that distinction because almost every decision created winners and losers.

Race and civil rights belonged at the centre of this education. Black and Puerto Rican New Yorkers were often approached as dependable electoral blocs rather than as citizens with different interests. Candidates spoke about them while still treating their communities as instruments of strategy. Character required a more exacting standard: listening without condescension, seeing structural injustice without turning people into symbols, and seeking solutions that did not ask one neighbourhood to celebrate its loss.

Character lives in public habits

Integrity is easier to describe than to locate. It lives in habits rather than declarations. It is present when a person keeps a small promise, corrects an error, refuses personal advantage, or accepts responsibility when the explanation would be less impressive. It also survives when nobody is watching closely enough to reward the behaviour.

This is why character has always mattered in fiction. A fictional person acquires depth through repeated choices, not through a statement of moral value. That conviction shaped my letter to my characters, written for their tenth birthday: imagined lives deserve sustained attention, and their author must remain answerable to the people created on the page.

Public character and private character overlap without being identical. A writer may be sensitive in private and careless in an argument. A public leader may appear warm on the campaign trail and evade scrutiny in an office. The test comes through patterns over time. Honest people can still be impatient, short-tempered or mistaken. What matters is whether they recognise the error, change the behaviour and resist the convenience of pretending the error never occurred.

Australia supplies its own mirror

Here the ballot reaches the citizen through compulsory enrolment, and voting day can involve a queue at a school hall in Sydney or a polling booth beside a familiar Melbourne tram route. Australians often take that regularity for granted. An overseas visitor might notice how rarely the machinery of democracy requires a dramatic act: identity checks, marked ballot papers, a pencil on a string and a volunteer directing traffic.

Civic life also takes less formal forms. The Saturday ritual of watching football, tending a barbecue and raising money at the local club creates bonds that can either strengthen or distort public life. Used well, the fundraiser reminds neighbours that leadership can mean sharing tables, carrying supplies and staying after the applause has ended. Used badly, it can turn community loyalty into a way of distributing preference to those already inside the circle.

Australian readers also recognise the public meeting in a council chamber or community hall, where residents question candidates about bins, roads, libraries and development. The scale is different from New York’s, yet the moral pressure is similar: public figures speak before people who will remember whether their promises survived contact with ordinary life. Local bookshops such as Readings in Melbourne, QBD in Brisbane, Dymocks and independent newsagency bookshops add another civic connection, keeping reading communities active in the local market rather than treating books as disposable transactions.

Signs of character worth watching

Public character can be tested against a handful of durable signs. None guarantees good leadership, but together they offer more evidence than a campaign slogan or a polished interview.

  • Keeps commitments that no longer provide political advantage, especially when meeting them creates inconvenience.
  • Corrects mistakes openly, gives credit generously and avoids disguising failure as somebody else’s error.
  • Treats opponents, reporters and service workers with the same basic respect shown to influential supporters.
  • Explains difficult trade-offs without pretending that one course of action is costless or morally perfect.

The same qualities can be observed outside office. Character becomes more credible when it appears consistently in less visible settings, where status offers no protection and applause is absent.

  • Listens before speaking, especially when someone has reason to distrust institutions or public promises.
  • Protects vulnerable people from blame, exposure or exploitation when institutional convenience suggests otherwise.
  • Distinguishes hope from evidence and remains willing to revise a position when facts become uncomfortable.
  • Leaves organisations, neighbourhoods and relationships stronger than it found them.

No single act establishes a person’s character. A generous donation beside an unjust dismissal, a brave statement beside a careless falsehood, these contradictions demand attention. Character is the pattern that develops when the convenient choice and the costly choice meet. It is measured by what becomes easier after a person has held power.

Read, then choose your ground

Character should not be confused with agreeability. The strongest people I have encountered were not universally liked, and some possessed flaws that tested every relationship around them. Their character appeared in their refusal to exploit weakness, their willingness to answer for failure and their insistence that other people deserved a fair hearing. Good judgement required more than moral vocabulary. It required evidence, humility and the capacity to change course without theatrical apology.

That lesson follows a person beyond politics. It shaped the observations gathered in An Irish Experience, where a journey through Ireland demanded attention to ordinary lives, inherited histories and the difference between welcome and courtesy. It also shaped Gideon’s Children, a novel in which inherited struggle becomes a test of responsibility across generations. Public achievement may place a person on a stage. Character determines what happens when the stage is no longer there.

Start with Gideon’s Children or An Irish Experience, and look for both titles through your preferred Australian bookseller or local library. Read with attention to the choices that shape each work, then carry that attention into public life. Vote carefully, attend the meeting where a decision is made, and judge every candidate by what remains true when no crowd is cheering.