Home
An open letter to the booksellers who stocked my first novel
Dear bookseller, when Gideon's Children, my first novel, arrived in your shop, the cover did only half the work. The rest was yours: placing it where a browsing reader might see it, saying something about it when asked, and perhaps ordering another copy before word of mouth had done its patient work. You were never obliged to become an evangelist. You were the bridge between a book and a reader.
That bridge is easy to overlook because a stocked title appears effortless. Behind every face-out copy sit decisions about returns, margins, staff time and finite shelf space. The bookseller must imagine the reader who wants this story, then trust that reader with it. When the exchange works, a shop becomes a place where reading is discovered.
For Australian booksellers, those choices come with familiar pressures. Books carry no GST, yet shops face city rents, wages, freight to regional towns and competition from online sellers. During BookMonth in August, a Melbourne or Sydney bookshop may recommend dozens of unfamiliar books in one month. The person at the counter cannot give each equal attention, so a specific, honest sentence can matter more than a large generic display.
I died in 2016, so I cannot revisit the shops that carried Gideon's Children or thank the booksellers who gave it room. This letter survives as a record of gratitude and a request. I am asking for no celebrity treatment and no inflated claim. I am asking that the next unfamiliar book be treated as a possible encounter rather than inventory.
The small decision that carried the book
A first novel enters a catalogue differently from a famous name. It has no familiar silhouette on the street, no pile of advance reviews and no audience waiting with a postcode. Its author may be unknown outside a small circle. For a bookseller, ordering it is a judgement about narrative, character and the public appetite for a subject that has not yet found its readers.
When Gideon's Children reached Australian shops, I understood that publicity alone could not keep it on the shelf. The novel draws on the civil-rights era and the consequences of racial prejudice, subjects that can repel readers when presented as abstractions. A brief response from someone who had read the book could turn those abstractions into a story with a doorway in it.
I want booksellers to remember a basic courtesy: they need not flatter a first novel to recommend it. “This is a demanding book, but the characters stay with you” is more useful than declaring every debut a masterpiece. Trust grows from candour. If the fit is wrong, direct the reader elsewhere; if it is right, that reader may carry the novel to a club, a friend or a family member.
The bookshop as a literary counter
In Australian speech, a “bookshop” sounds warmer than “bookstore,” and the best examples earn that warmth through local knowledge. A counter in a Sydney suburb, a shop reached through a Melbourne laneway or a second-hand dealer in Canberra is more than a retail floor. It is a desk where questions are exchanged: What do you feel like reading? Which book has been waiting for its reader?
That role has grown as catalogue browsing has moved to phones and laptops. A customer can obtain a replacement copy in moments, but speed does not answer why this novel should matter. Booksellers preserve the slower intelligence of browsing: seeing a title beside an essay on the same theme, noticing a reader pause, hearing a sentence that sends someone to nonfiction for context. These are acts of literary mediation.
They also become a public voice. A bookseller quoted in a local paper, invited onto radio or asked to introduce a reading can lend a new writer credibility without impersonating a celebrity. Visibility matters in regional Australia, where distance makes a personal recommendation valuable and the nearest shelves may be reached by mail rather than a short drive. One well-chosen copy can travel farther than its buyer expects.
What stocking a first novel actually involves
The first sale is never the whole story. A debut needs copies to meet early interest, exposure to provoke conversation and time to find readers who will recommend it later. The bookseller sees this pressure more clearly than the author, who can mistake attention for momentum. It is fair dinkum difficult to order with confidence when every copy risks becoming unsold stock, but modest actions can change the odds.
Ways to make a debut easier to find
Put the novel on a visible table with a handwritten note naming its subject, its author and the reader it may suit. Ask a staff member to read it and give one specific response, even if that response includes a reservation about length or tone. Display it beside essays, interviews or historical writing that illuminate the questions behind the story. Let customers order a single copy through the trade without requiring a large speculative shipment.
None of this asks you to misrepresent the book. It asks for the same thoughtful introduction you would give a title with obvious sales appeal. A reader entering through history, morality or family may still discover the novel's power; a reader entering through an honest sentence about its characters may stay for the whole journey.
Counter space and staff hours are finite. A catalogue made only of certain names also becomes difficult to navigate. A first novel is part of the ecology that keeps literature alive. A bookseller's patient judgement can decide whether that ecology expands or narrows.
Visibility, trust and the stories behind a book
No amount of placement substitutes for trust, especially when a novel asks readers to encounter uncomfortable history. Reviews, excerpts, author interviews and conversations among booksellers can explain the questions a book asks without giving away the answers. They offer context while preserving mystery. A reader should finish an interview curious about the next chapter, not fully briefed by the display card.
I examined that tension in On the Lies We Tell Ourselves in Autobiography, where memory, self-justification and the shaping of a life become matters of record as well as craft. The same care belongs with fiction. An introduction can say that Gideon's Children deals with race, conscience and the cost of historical change, but it should not tell a reader how to feel.
This is why the staff recommendation remains precious. It can name the experience honestly: what changes in the reader's understanding, which characters feel urgent, whether the prose suits a particular mood. It can also invite conversation. Gideon's Children carries civil-rights history into personal and moral terrain. A reader needs a human signpost, not a slogan.
My later travelogue, An Irish Experience, came out of a similar belief in discovery through stories. Ireland's history is not scenery for a visitor; it is carried by voices, arguments, music and memory. The same is true in Australia, where cities and regions have their own accents and histories, and where a bookseller who knows the local mood can guide readers toward books that speak to it. That purpose connects both books and the discussions on my website.
A fairer bargain between authors and booksellers
Authors often imagine a bookseller's decision as a vote for the work. Sometimes it is, but it is also a cash-flow decision. Wholesale terms, sale-or-return arrangements, discounts, unsold stock and display costs shape what can be tried. In Australia, that calculation stretches from high-rent metropolitan shops to booksellers serving large distances and thin populations. Demanding equal stock for every unknown book would misunderstand the business; asking for thoughtful treatment within it is reasonable.
Changes that cost little but matter
Give first novels a fair place in themed displays and on tables where staff can explain the choice. Take customer orders for single copies when the economics of a larger order are uncertain. Pass useful feedback to the publisher or author, including the sort of reader who responds strongly to the book. Invite local book clubs, reading groups or interview evenings to discuss new writing alongside established favourites.
A bookseller should also be able to decline without feeling negligent. An honest “not for our customers” is service, not betrayal. The useful relationship is reciprocal: the author listens to market realities, and the bookseller receives enough communication to judge the next book with more than a synopsis. Trust does not require blind risk; it requires a clearer exchange.
For Gideon's Children, persistence would have built a public able to discuss civil rights, family and moral courage through narrative rather than lecture. For my nonfiction, it would have invited readers to cross a sea and meet another culture on its own terms. A bookseller can begin that exchange. The return may come later in a recommendation, a reread or another author brought to the counter.
Please make room for the unfamiliar
I began with a simple truth: a book is not finished when it is printed. It waits for a reader, and often for the bookseller who puts the right reader beside it. Gideon's Children began as a first novel with a difficult, necessary subject; An Irish Experience became a travelogue about looking and being changed. Both depended on readers willing to cross a threshold and shops prepared to show them where it stood.
Copies of both books can be sought through booksellers such as Dauphin de Lumiere. My website records their publication details and gathers blog writing, excerpts, reviews, biographical details and recorded conversations, offering paths into the work. The purpose is not to make a monument of an author; it is to keep the exchange with readers moving.
So I ask you to choose the next unfamiliar book with care, tell a reader what it offers, and make it easy to find another copy when the first has done its work. Keep recommending first novels. Share their interviews. Host the conversation. Put them where hands can reach them. Stock the next unfamiliar book, recommend it by name and give its author the chance to become a reader's trusted writer.