Home
On being a white writer who writes about Black lives
I am white, and that fact sits underneath every sentence I write about Black lives. It is not a defect to be managed with a few careful sentences. It is a condition of my perspective: one that shapes where I begin, what I think I understand, and where a reader may reasonably distrust me. The honest work begins by keeping that condition visible.
That visibility matters most in a novel such as Gideon’s Children. Fiction can open a door into a life unlike the writer’s own, yet it can also turn difference into a device for explaining the author’s values. I wanted Black lives in that book to remain more than instruments of moral argument. They are lives of appetite, error, memory, ambition and ordinary care, not problems waiting for a white outsider to solve them.
The same responsibility follows me into essays about civil rights, race and public memory. Writing about another person’s experience does not grant possession of it. My task is narrower and harder: to attend carefully, question my assumptions, and accept that some knowledge will remain partial. A writer can earn a place in a difficult subject through humility and sustained work; inheritance alone cannot do it.
The qualification behind the authority
My whiteness does not disqualify me from examining racial inequality. The misleading claim would be that it does, because such a claim erases the writers who have made a life’s work of exposing systems shaped by race. Nor should I pretend my identity is irrelevant. White readers have been taught to see certain people as familiar, others as exceptional and distant. That habit of perception enters a sentence before the writer becomes conscious of it.
My Irish ancestry gives me a personal history of migration, class and belonging, but it does not provide a ready analogy to Black experience in the United States. Irish history contains exclusion, religious prejudice and struggles over civil rights, yet those histories have their own structures. They should not be used as a shortcut that converts one painful history into another or treats Black lives as a darker version of a familiar white story.
Authority and authenticity are separate questions. Research can strengthen the authority of a writer, while the limits of research should keep that writer from claiming authenticity. I can study how racism operates in a school, a police force or a family. I cannot reproduce the interior weather of a person who lives inside it. The writing grows stronger when this gap is acknowledged rather than concealed beneath authoritative prose.
Distance is not the same as ignorance
Distance can produce avoidance, but it can also make sustained observation possible. A writer outside a community may lack certain ease, yet that lack of ease can expose habits of entitlement. It can force the writer to ask better questions, consult more widely and distinguish between a detail that has been earned through attention and one added because it sounds plausible.
Imagination has obligations. It should not be used as a licence to turn people into representatives of a political idea. A fictional character may disagree with me, disappoint me and make choices I would not make. When every Black character in a story supports the author’s final position, the writer has probably concealed the people inside the argument. Real lives resist neat thematic use because they contain habits, loyalties, boredom and contradictions that exceed any lesson.
People with direct experience of the subject must also enter the process. Their response can be invaluable, particularly when a writer risks exoticising a community or treating a familiar wound as a source of atmosphere. Consultation should occur while revision remains possible. A late courtesy reading cannot repair years of assumptions, but an early conversation can reveal where a scene depends upon a story about Black life that the writer has borrowed from elsewhere.
Characters are people, not arguments
The hardest discipline is to let a character remain more than a lesson. Black lives in fiction deserve the same density that white characters often receive: private routines, material worries, imperfect memories and changes of mind. Their dialogue should not serve as a polished explanation of racism. Their silence should not automatically signal depth. A person is not a cryptic object waiting to be interpreted by a more thoughtful outsider.
The title Gideon’s Children suggests inheritance, but inheritance rarely arrives as a neat set of instructions. History passes through families in fragments: a warning, a habit, a silence, an argument about what happened. A novel can show how public systems enter private lives, yet the people carrying those systems must retain the right to exceed the writer’s scheme. Their futures cannot be used to certify that the story reached a hopeful ending.
Precision offers a useful warning. A technical account of skull base anatomy can map structures with extraordinary care, yet the map is not the person who lives within the body. The parallel has limits: race is not an anatomical condition. It does show why labels and tidy diagrams cannot replace attention to a particular life.
Questions and habits for responsible writing
Ethical intention becomes meaningful when it alters the page. A writer may begin with a sincere wish to confront prejudice, then make choices that reproduce the distance the project hoped to close. The practical work lies in revising those choices, testing the assumptions beneath them and accepting criticism from people better placed to identify their effects.
I keep two sets of questions close while drafting. They do not guarantee a responsible book, but they make responsibility concrete at the desk.
Questions before drafting:
- Who holds the point of view, and why does the story need that viewpoint?
- Which details come from observation, reliable research or convenient invention?
- Where am I asking a character to confirm an assumption about Black life?
- What does the character know, want, conceal and risk independently of my argument?
- Which reader might recognise the scene as a familiar cultural performance?
Habits before publication:
- Invite readers with relevant experience to respond while substantial revision remains possible.
- Credit oral histories, scholarship and community knowledge in verifiable ways.
- Replace broad labels with particular histories, circumstances and forms of language.
- Read dialogue aloud and test whether it sounds distinct from generic speech.
- Remove scenes where misunderstanding exists solely to move the plot.
These questions keep the writer’s attention on choices rather than declarations of goodwill. They also reveal when a scene needs more research, a different perspective or removal altogether. Perfection is not the standard; accountability is.
Writing into an Australian present
The subject changes when it enters a new country. In Australia, Black lives cannot be treated as a single export from the United States. African Australian communities, migrants from Africa and the Caribbean, and other Black diasporas have developed their own histories. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples possess distinct sovereignties, cultures and histories of survival and should never be folded into a generic category of Black experience.
At many Australian public events, speakers now open with an Acknowledgement of Country, naming the Kulin Nations in Melbourne, Gadigal Country in Sydney, or the Turrbal and Jagera Countries in Brisbane. The custom can become routine, yet its best expression establishes that a gathering takes place on land with an enduring history. For a writer, that recognition also asks how race, place, colonial power and belonging intersect without allowing one framework to swallow the others.
The settings of discussion matter too. Melbourne’s tram bells and café conversations create a familiar public rhythm, while Sydney’s George Street carries the languages and histories of migration in plain view. Brisbane’s subtropical light changes the pace and mood of a room. These details are not decorative local colour. They remind an Australian reader that racial identity is lived through particular streets, institutions, weather and communities, never through an abstract map of the world.
The Australian market for books offers its own conditions. Readings in Melbourne and QBD in Brisbane sit alongside independent bookshops, public libraries, audiobook subscriptions and online retailers across the country. A responsible writer enters that market as a participant in a public exchange. The audience includes readers who have encountered racial argument elsewhere and readers whose own lives are routinely reduced to evidence in somebody else’s argument.
Reading with the door open
Publishing a novel or memoir makes private choices available for public examination. A reader may challenge a characterisation, identify an omission or recognise a scene that has been made too clean. Such responses should not be treated as attacks on the writer’s motives. They are part of the ethical life of a book, especially when the subject reaches beyond the writer’s own community.
Gideon’s Children carries the questions discussed here into fictional form. An Irish Experience approaches identity, memory and belonging through the texture of travel and recollection. Read together, the books invite attention to how a person is shaped by history while still remaining more than the history assigned to them.
Find Gideon’s Children and An Irish Experience through Readings, QBD, Dymocks, your nearest independent Australian bookseller or a public library. Read them with attention, recommend them through your own networks and continue the discussion wherever booksellers, libraries and reading groups make space for it. Read closely, respond honestly, and keep the conversation moving.