Why I Avoid Calling My Own Work a Journey

I have a long-standing distrust of the word journey, at least when I am doing the writing. It sounds harmless, and most of the time it is. It is also one of those words that can conceal more than it explains. A journey can be a bus ride, a migration, an argument with the past, or a metaphor for a life reorganised around hope. The sentence sounds complete before we have learned what actually happened.

The difficulty is not the dictionary definition. It is the freight the word brings with it: departure, struggle, discovery and eventual arrival. Put those stages into an opening paragraph, and a reader may assume the route, the lesson and the destination before the writer has earned any of them. What should remain uncertain can arrive pre-packaged as wisdom.

I avoid it because I want the particulars to carry the weight. A character gets on a particular train, a family waits for a telephone call, a town receives a visitor with the wrong expectations. Such details resist easy moral summaries. They make room for contradiction, inconvenience and the possibility that a person travels without becoming a better person.

That habit shaped the titles and the texture of my books. In Gideon’s Children, civil rights, memory and inherited responsibility matter more than the mythology of progress. In An Irish Experience, I wanted a title that allowed uncertainty rather than promising revelation. On this site, the books, excerpts, reviews, interviews and reflections are gathered for readers who may value that kind of attention.

A word that arrives with baggage

It helps to separate a useful word from a lazy one. Travel writing can be called a journey, and readers understand the term. Yet in reviews, essays and publishing descriptions, it often slides into odyssey, quest or passage without adding anything. Those words create an impression of importance. They place a halo around an ordinary movement and encourage us to interpret the experience as necessary.

The word can also impose a tidy sequence. There is the person who leaves, the obstacle overcome and the wiser person who arrives. Real life offers no such guarantee. Some crossings repeat; some destinations disappoint; some changes bring loss without a compensating gain. Calling all of that a journey smooths away the discomfort that makes honest writing worth reading.

I therefore object to the word mainly when it replaces attention, not when it names a movement accurately. The distinction matters. A coach travels along a highway. A memoir may describe an apprenticeship, a migration or a return. Those are precise terms. A broad metaphor is warranted only when its looseness opens a truth that exact language would conceal.

From personal change to lived experience

The phrase personal journey is especially troublesome because it turns change into a private possession. Writers are invited to reveal an inner transformation, while the social conditions surrounding that change fall out of view. Money, housing, work, policing, language and family obligation do not disappear merely because the person at the centre of the story has learned something.

That is why I chose An Irish Experience for my memoir and travelogue. The title makes no promise of a grand explanatory account. It says that Ireland has been experienced, and experience may be partial, surprising or unfinished. The name leaves room for the place to resist the visitor’s expectations, and for the visitor to be changed without claiming mastery.

Civil-rights activism taught me something similar. A campaign is not automatically a heroic procession, and suffering does not guarantee moral progress. In writing about the struggles documented in my blog and in Gideon’s Children, I prefer the pressure of particular events to a polished story about personal triumph. A name, a meeting or a remembered act can say more than a grand label.

The ethics of a simpler route

Precision also keeps material circumstances in view. Across Sydney, a toll road can alter the morning; in Melbourne, a tram can turn a missed connection into a significant part of the day. A takeaway flat white carried in a reusable cup may occupy as much space in an ordinary routine as a delayed train. These details are not distractions from an alleged deeper meaning. They are the conditions in which an encounter happens.

Place is never just scenery. I am especially careful when writing about Ireland, Australia or the United States not to turn a country into a backdrop for the traveller’s private insight. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander writing makes the ethical stakes plain: Country is not a metaphor awaiting an outsider’s discovery. If my account blurs that distinction, better diction will not repair it.

Other verbs do the work more honestly. A person crosses, returns, departs, migrates or waits. A season turns. A road changes. A family gathers. These are not automatically superior words; they are simply less presumptuous. Sometimes movement is the subject. Sometimes the real story is what happens when no one gets very far.

What my books try to make visible

In Gideon’s Children, the title invokes inheritance rather than itinerary. The novel considers how public history enters private lives and how families carry responsibility across generations. Civil rights appear as lived pressure, not a decorative lesson for an audience far removed from the risks involved. That approach is one reason I resist the easy assurances of a narrative that treats every trial as preparation for a rewarding destination.

An Irish Experience follows a different scale. A travelogue can become a catalogue of impressions unless the writer admits a personal stake in what is being observed. My title keeps that stake visible without turning Ireland into a mirror for the author’s self-regard. It also reminds me that the encounter is partial: one person’s days, conversations and misreadings cannot stand in for a whole society.

My own path from journalism and civil-rights activism into fiction was not a clean ascent. Writing gave those concerns another duration. A newspaper report answers the pressure of the day; a novel can revisit a silence years later. That difference is why I prefer an unfinished question to a word such as journey, which tends to close the matter before the work has properly begun.

Better habits for precise and humane prose

Published writing also has a market and a legal setting. In Australia, the Australian Consumer Law governs accurate price presentation and misleading claims, while the Copyright Act 1968 matters when published words are quoted or reused. Independent bookshops, national online retailers, council-run libraries and digital formats now place books in a crowded market. Clear prose cannot guarantee sales, but it can keep the promise made to the reader.

Several habits have helped me resist grand language without making the work cautious or mechanical:

  • Replace abstract movement with an observable action. “She left Melbourne on the early tram” tells us more than “She began her journey.”
  • Name the resistance. A delayed ferry, a closed road, a divided family or an uncertain job makes a crossing more than scenery.
  • Separate change from improvement. A person may move house, lose a language or find work and still feel deeply unsettled.
  • Keep arrivals ambiguous. A meeting can open a question instead of neatly resolving it.
  • Let place retain its own weight. Mention the street, weather, shopfront and fare, rather than only the feeling the writer hopes they produce.
  • Read for false grandeur. If journey, odyssey or transformative can be removed without loss, a more exact verb may be waiting.

These habits need not make a manuscript stiff. They make its scale more exact. If a reader can picture the tram, the borrowed room, the unpaid bill or the unanswered letter, the passage has a chance of carrying emotional truth. The aim is not to remove all metaphor, but to earn each one.

A clearer invitation to read and respond

Reading is the final test of this approach. My books ask for attention to other people’s words and withheld histories, and their pages here offer publication information, excerpts, reviews and links to booksellers. Howard G. Franklin died in 2016, but this site preserves the biography, interviews and reflections that explain the books’ concerns and keeps them available to readers.

Begin with an excerpt from Gideon’s Children or An Irish Experience, then follow the links to purchase a copy through a bookseller serving Australia. Explore the essays on literature, Ireland, civil rights and race, and listen to the archived media interviews. If a passage gives you pause, write about it in your own reading group or review. The point is not to settle every argument, but to keep meeting other people’s words with care.