Writing toward readers who would rather look away

Writing about race for an audience that wants to look away is not an exercise in persuasion. It is a test of whether a story can make inherited power visible without treating human beings as instruments in an argument. The work of the late Howard G. Franklin, who died in 2016, repeatedly takes on that test. In Gideon’s Children, in his civil-rights reflections, and in An Irish Experience, history enters through memory, silence, obligation, and suspicion. The past is something characters carry, perform, misread, and sometimes resist.

For Australian readers, the impulse to turn away has familiar settings. Someone may browse the shelves of a Carlton bookshop, take a tram past the university, and leave with a novel whose social conflicts feel safer than the racial histories running through the news. At a Sydney gathering, the phrase “we’ve come a long way” may close an argument before anyone asks who has been left behind. These are not uniquely Australian habits, but local speech gives them a distinct cadence, joining warmth, embarrassment, and a wish not to make a fuss.

A familiar way of changing the subject

Readerly avoidance rarely announces itself as hostility. A reader may praise a book for being “important,” then ask for more humour, a romance, or a reassuring message. This is the bargain many readers bring to difficult fiction: grant me a window into another life, but keep the glass clean. The writer accepts the terms by adding a charming subplot, postponing the hardest truth, or ending with an apology in a final chapter.

Australian conversational habits can sharpen that bargain. “Give it a fair go” may mean a sincere appeal for consideration, yet it can also imply that exposure itself is unfair. The “tall poppy” is supposed to have its head cut down, but the sharper version of the phrase is used against people whose confidence appears to threaten the group. A Black Australian character who speaks forcefully may therefore be asked to soften, while a character who appears respectable is granted the audience’s trust. Silence becomes easier than disagreement.

The writer’s task is not to scold readers for their defences. Defences are material, and they often reveal where a society believes its stories have ended. The task is to make the story precise enough that no reader can confuse discomfort with danger. If a book merely allows white readers to feel awakened, it has not entered the difficult conversation; it has converted that conversation into another form of reassurance.

History that will not remain background

Fiction cannot reproduce history, but it can show how history continues to issue instructions. A parent teaches a child which doors are safe, which names are respectable, and which memories may not be spoken at a family table. These instructions can look like temperament until a larger pattern emerges. The character’s prejudice, shame, curiosity, or tenderness then becomes an inheritance in motion rather than a fact printed in a profile.

That inheritance differs according to place. The forced removal of Aboriginal children and the continuing sovereignty of First Nations peoples cannot be folded into the history of chattel slavery in the United States, just as African American experiences under Jim Crow should not be made a vague stand-in for every experience of racialisation. Irish poverty, sectarian division, and colonial rule form another field. Franklin’s writing can connect these histories through method: examine the systems around a person, while refusing to flatten distinct forms of violence into one universal grievance.

A character need not become a spokesperson for a people for history to matter. A Black nurse in Brisbane, a public servant in Dublin, or a family member in Harlem may have interests that are intensely private. The narrative becomes stronger when those private aims complicate the historical role assigned to the character. Ancestry explains pressures; it does not predetermine the choice made under them.

Character is not a spokesperson

The quickest way to lose a difficult reader is to turn a person into a lesson. Characters begin to speak in polished paragraphs about discrimination, conveniently appearing when the author needs a position proved. Their dialect disappears, their appetites become politically correct, and the reader recognises a mouthpiece rather than a life. Avoiding that trap requires attention to the ordinary things a character wants even when no crisis is near.

Franklin’s reflections on characters carrying heavy pasts consider how inherited experience becomes action rather than exposition. A burdened character may conceal a humiliation, repeat an old command, accept a job for security, or lie to protect a parent. The important point is not that every gesture must encode history. It is that a writer should know which pressures shaped the character and allow those pressures to create contradiction.

Complexity is not a synonym for moral neutrality. Giving a racist character a tender memory does not excuse the harm, and giving a victim a flawed response does not weaken the account of what was done to them. The ethical centre comes from proportion: the narration must remain alert to consequences while refusing to make punishment the only form of interest. Readers are asked to see a whole person, not to decide the character’s goodness every page.

Difficult books in the Australian market

The Australian book market gives a racial narrative a peculiar set of gates. Many titles travel from manuscripts in Melbourne or Sydney through national distributors, large booksellers, online retailers, and independent shops. Literary prizes, festival panels, radio interviews, and reviewers can extend a book’s life, but they also influence how it is packaged. Terms such as “race,” “trauma,” or “identity” may promise seriousness while narrowing the imagination of what the novel can do.

A writer can respond by making the book less political, which sometimes protects it and sometimes betrays it. Another response is to exaggerate the conflict so that no one can accuse the novel of timidity. Both can flatten difficult material into a marketable shape. Australian readers have learned to value directness, yet they are also unlikely to reward a book that behaves like a seminar with characters attached.

There is room for more specific routes. Community publishers, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander-led imprints, university presses, literary magazines, and independent bookshops in Adelaide, Canberra, Hobart, and regional centres can connect a book with readers who recognise the stakes or know the history. These channels do not guarantee a commercial career, and they should not be romanticised. They do show how a literary culture can circulate work that national headlines and prize lists overlook.

Discomfort without spectacle

Discomfort becomes an instrument when the author’s need to expose hypocrisy outruns the reader’s ability to recognise another consciousness. The scene then works as a trap. It asks the audience to feel ashamed for looking, while the character remains fixed as an object of instruction. This is why the presence of difficult detail does not automatically make fiction ethically serious. Purpose matters, as does the distribution of power within the page.

A more demanding approach is to let readers sit with uncertainty. That uncertainty should arise from honest gaps in knowledge, conflicting loyalties, and incomplete evidence, not from a refusal to supply information. Franklin’s civil-rights perspective is useful here because it understands that systems are made from ordinary decisions and then protected by ordinary habits. One person declines to intervene. Another invents a neutral rule. Repetition turns those acts into a climate.

Writing for an audience inclined to look away also means resisting the fantasy that awareness creates automatic change. A reader may close a book shaken, admirable, unchanged. The writer cannot control what travels beyond the page. What can be controlled is the quality of attention the book demands: whether its silences have causes, whether its people retain agency, and whether its ending opens a responsibility rather than dispensing absolution.

A working method for honest writing

Begin with pressure rather than explanation. Find a scene in which a character must act while history, memory, and reputation pull in different directions. This makes the subject part of lived narrative without turning the character into a diagram. It also gives readers something harder than information: a choice they must interpret.

Then test the manuscript against the people it represents, without asking them to certify the writer’s goodness. Accuracy is not endorsement, and criticism should be welcomed even when it challenges the structure of the book. A conversation with a reader can reveal assumptions that have become invisible through familiarity. The aim is not consensus, but a text less likely to confuse an imagined community with a real one.

  • Make the past exert pressure: connect history to choices, relationships, and consequences rather than using it as a decorative explanation.
  • Give characters private desires, contradictions, and loyalties that exceed any role assigned to them by race or history.
  • Research the specific history before generalising from it, and distinguish documented fact from the writer’s fictional inference.
  • Treat silence as deliberate and situational, revealing what a character fears, protects, or cannot yet say.
  • Avoid making discomfort the proof of virtue; test whether each difficult scene deepens character or merely displays the writer’s moral courage.
  • Read drafts with readers connected to the communities portrayed, receiving their objections as essential craft feedback rather than a demand for approval.
  • Resist false resolution, especially when an ending tidies away harm that the story has taken care to render honestly.

Howard G. Franklin’s books remain useful because they refuse the convenience of distance. Gideon’s Children offers a narrative in which inherited conflict becomes personal action, while An Irish Experience carries the same scrutiny into place, memory, and encounter. The essays on this site extend that work into literature, Ireland, civil rights, and the private business of paying attention.

Read the excerpts and blog, follow the publication details for Gideon’s Children and An Irish Experience, and purchase the books through a local Australian bookseller. Support writers who make discomfort honest rather than comfortable, and carry the harder questions into your own conversations.